5 Common Mistakes Made When Valuing a Business for Sale
Setting the right price for your business is the most critical factor in a successful sale. If you price it too high, buyers won't even look at the listing, letting your valuable listing grow stale. If you price it too low, you'll leave years of hard-earned equity on the table.
For business owners in Shoreline and along the Connecticut Shoreline, your business is more than a building or a balance sheet—it’s a legacy. However, that deeply personal connection can be the biggest obstacle to an objective, financially sound business valuation.
At First Choice Business Brokers - Shoreline, we are authorities in business sales. Our proprietary process ensures your valuation is accurate, justifiable, and structured to maximize your return. Here are the five most common and costly mistakes we see sellers make, and how a professional business broker prevents them.
1: Using an Emotional Price Tag Instead of Fair Market Value
We understand. You poured your blood, sweat, and tears into this business. You know its history, its struggles, and the future potential you know is there. This emotional investment often leads to "seller fantasy pricing"—a price based on what you need or feel should be worth, not what the market will bear.
The Financial Reality Check
A buyer doesn't pay for your past effort; they pay for the future cash flow the business can reliably generate. The price must be supported by comparable sales (Market Approach) and the company's actual performance (Income Approach).
An over-priced business immediately signals to professional buyers (who work with Shoreline business brokers that the seller is unrealistic, often leading them to walk away without making an offer, no matter how attractive the business is.
2: Mistaking an Asset Sale for a Business Sale
"Well, I have $200,000 in equipment and $50,000 in inventory, so it’s worth at least $250,000."
This is a classic mistake, particularly with established service, retail, or manufacturing businesses. This approach—an Asset-Based Valuation—only tells you what you could get by liquidating the company, not what a buyer would pay to step into a turnkey, profitable operation.
The Power of Intangible Value (Goodwill)
The actual value in most operating businesses lies in the intangible assets, often referred to as Goodwill. This includes:
- Established Customer Base and Recurring Revenue
- Trained, Competent Staff and Management Systems
- Brand Reputation and Location Advantage (critical in Shoreline)
- Proprietary Processes or Contracts
A professional FCBB Shoreline business broker valuation captures this intangible value, often increasing the final sale price by hundreds of thousands compared to a mere asset-based calculation.
3: Ignoring Seller Discretionary Earnings (SDE) Adjustments
If you have used your business to pay for personal expenses—a vehicle lease, family health insurance, travel, or excess compensation—you have effectively understated the company's true profitability.
Seller Discretionary Earnings (SDE) are a core metric in small business valuation. They represent the total economic benefit your business provides to a single owner-operator.
Normalizing the Financials
A broker will perform a meticulous process of recasting or normalizing your financial statements. This involves adding back:
- Non-Recurring/Extraordinary Expenses: One-time legal fees, equipment repairs, or large, unusual contracts.
- Owner Benefits and Perquisites (Perks): Personal cars, travel, excessive life insurance premiums, or non-business related utilities.
- Excess Owner Compensation: The difference between what the owner took out and what a market-rate manager would cost.
By accurately calculating a high SDE, we demonstrate the maximum earning power of the business to a qualified buyer, justifying a higher price. Without these adjustments, your company looks less profitable than it truly is.
4: Relying Solely on Simple "Rules of Thumb" Multiples
In online forums or casual discussions, you might hear a "rule of thumb," such as "restaurants sell for 1x annual revenue" or "service companies sell for 3x SDE." While these industry multiples offer a quick, rough estimate, using them as your sole valuation method is dangerous.
Why Rules of Thumb Fall Short
No two businesses are identical, especially in a market like the Connecticut Shoreline. A generic multiple fails to account for:
- Risk Profile: A business with a single, large client is riskier (and worth less) than one with 100 small, diversified clients.
- Transferability: A business heavily dependent on the owner’s personal relationships is worth less than one with documented, transferable systems.
- Market Conditions: Local Shoreline real estate trends or specific industry competition in the immediate area can drastically affect the multiple.
A proper valuation employs at least three different methods (Income Approach, Market Approach, Asset Approach) to arrive at a defensible, weighted conclusion.
5: Trying a DIY Valuation to "Save Money"
The final, and perhaps most damaging, mistake is attempting to determine the final sale price yourself to avoid the cost of a professional valuation.
Professional buyers and their advisors immediately dismiss a self-performed valuation. It lacks the impartiality, methodology, and legal defensibility required during the intense due diligence process.
The Broker’s Credibility
Hiring a certified business broker in Shoreline, like First Choice Business Broker, ensures:
- Impartiality: The valuation is objective and free of emotional bias, providing a realistic market perspective.
- Justification: We provide a comprehensive report that legally and financially justifies the asking price to lenders, buyers, and their CPAs.
- Negotiation Power: A certified valuation report significantly strengthens your position, giving you the confidence and data to negotiate the highest possible price.
Don’t risk losing hundreds of thousands of dollars or wasting months with a stale listing. Investing in a professional valuation is the single best way to ensure a fast, confidential, and maximum-value sale.
Ready to Price Your Business for a Maximum Sale?
The valuation process is the foundation of a successful exit. As your trusted partner in business sales, First Choice Business Brokers—Shoreline can provide the expert, confidential valuation you need to move forward confidently.
Don't guess your business's value—know its value.
Contact us today for a free, confidential consultation and take the first step toward a strategic, profitable sale.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Fair Market Value (FMV), and how is it different from my asking price?
FMV is the highest price a willing, informed buyer would pay to a willing, informed seller, assuming neither is compelled to act. Your asking price, while based on the FMV, is the initial number the broker sets to allow for negotiation.
Do I need a complete valuation if I already have a "ballpark" figure from my CPA?
Yes. Most CPAs provide tax-related valuations, which often minimize value for tax purposes. A broker's valuation maximizes the economic value for a sale. A third-party valuation report is essential to withstand buyer due diligence and secure financing from lenders.
How long does the professional business valuation process take?
Once we receive all necessary financial documents (typically 3 years of P&Ls and tax returns), First Choice Business Brokers—Shoreline generally takes 2 to 4 weeks to complete a full, detailed valuation.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog post by First Choice Business Brokers - Shoreline is for informational purposes only. Business valuation is a complex process dependent on numerous factors, including current market conditions, specific business performance, and available financing. This content does not constitute financial, accounting, or legal advice. Readers should consult a certified business broker, CPA, and legal counsel for advice tailored to their situation.
Recent articles for you
